So many loopholes. Prue was and always will be my favorite charmed one. Welcome Guest. Episode 18 42 mins. I don't deny it. She was supposed to develop new and strong power. Ultimately, after vanquishing the Darklighter Rennek and absorbing the Empyreal Sword, the Grimoire and the All into herself, she became the host and the connection between Earth to the Upper Regions and to the Underworld. Hello C:RR people!! You either have some issues or are a huge Prue fan. Give me the access, and I can fix Aug 1, 2017 13:50:15 GMT -5 Proboards moved most of the banner images to somewhere hidden but I've restored all the themes to their former glory. Just my thoughts. "The Controversy of Prue Halliwell's Death", "STAR TREK VOYAGER" RETROSPECTIVE: (3.24) “Displaced”, "The Fashion Sense of Good Girls Who Go Bad", (4.01 - 4.02) "CHARMED AGAIN" - Retrospective. I can see why people would say that it was Phoebe's fault or Prue's own fault, but I was of the opinion that it was like one of those movies where somewone dies and you had a chance to relive the day and the other person dies and it's tragic. I liked it better without Prue anyways. I loved the Prue character and Shannon played the part so well that I'm glad they decided to kill off Prue's character rather than recast her. , The icons are gone! As far as I know Prue wasnt meant to die, but Shannen was fired, that's why it was a strange ending to season 3. This comment has been removed by the author. Its a tv show...they wanted Shannon Dougherty off the show so they wrote her out. Phoebe is selfish. I'm normally too lazy to put anything that researched in my blogposts. Prudence "Prue" Halliwell was is one of the four main protagonists of the 1998-2006 television series, Charmed. Wow! But since its literally dead, I'm.not sure how we can accomplish that. how come she is totally out of the story? Like how leo can't save prue, but he was saved by piper when he died before when they switched powers. She could've been the strongest witch of all time. (Like on new posts, board statistics etc). "LOST" - (5.11) "Whatever Happened, Happened" (Or ... "Janeway's Decision in (3.04) "THE SWARM". Though Prue initially chose to keep her distance from her sisters out of fear of the cataclysmic consequences, she eventually decided to return to San Francisco when her youngest sister, Paige Matthews, arrived in search of a candidate for Magic School who worked at "Salem Witch House", and was happily reunited with Piper and Phoebe. The sisters face being separated, as newlyweds Piper and Leo plan to get their own home. Give me the access, and I can fix. She could also access The Power of Three, the collective power of the Charmed Ones. They needed a way to get rid of Prue and thus they killed her off. (Like on new posts, board statistics etc). Shannen was leaving the show. Prue staves off the Angel of Death while trying to save someone's life. It's a show and yes it's sad when a major character is killed off but there's always room for other beloved character's to arrive. Prue Halliwell (Shannen Doherty) Following Prue's death at the end of Charmed season 4, her obituary confirmed her birth date as being October 28, 1970. Great post. The show seemed to be too much about her at times. (Like on new posts, board statistics etc). But Prue and Piper should have refused to help send her to the Source's Realm until the situation with Shax was genuinely settled. Prudence Halliwell was born on October 28, 1970 in San Francisco, California. viewers deserve it. Played by Shannen Doherty, Prue Halliwell entered the series as the eldest sister to Piper (Holly Marie Combs) and Phoebe Halliwell (Alyssa Milano). It was essentially her selfishness that got Prue killed. Her Wiccan powers were focused on mind and movement: the ability to move objects with her mind, and the ability to project herself in an astral form. Hope you're having a great April! Aaaaargh! Charmed was a great show when Prue was apart of it. Prue Halliwell is the oldest child of Phoebe Halliwell and Coop. It was sad, but I accepted it. I hope so. Piper Halliwell: The icons are gone! On March 24, 1975, she was visited by a future version of herself. She hardly even cried when Prue died, again making things all about Cole. She didnt care. She cared more about "saving" Cole than helping her sisters. Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. Click here to remove banner ads from this forum. the first born witch child was supposed to be the strongest. Amen to what James Lenaghan said. The show didn't even bother to explain why they can't talk to prue just like grams and patty. She is engaged to Aiden Sawyer, who is half human and half Manticore demon. And yes, you'll tell me that was because of Prue and Piper's mistake, but once again,had Phoebe stayed in the manor, she and her sisters would've dealed with Shax and nobody would've died. I cant believe i forgot to say this in my last comment. Shannon was overtaking the show - every episode was about Prue and how badass she is, instead if it been called Charmed it should of been called Prudence. However, Prue had actually disappeared and Patty gave Cole Turner the task of finding her. She asked her sisters to send her to underworld where they wouldn't be able to contact her. Prudence "Prue" Halliwell was the oldest of the four Halliwell sisters, taking care of her younger sisters Piper and Phoebe. It was ruined. Hollys crying was 100% real while Alyssas was so fake you could tell by just listening to it. She could also access The Power of Three, the collective power of the Charmed Ones. Prue and Piper may have been reckless, but they weren't selfish. It is definitely not 100% dead. (Even though I do have a wife and a kid.. soon 2), Happy National Constitution day Norway!!!!!!! So what happened to prue? some things are out of your hands. It never occured to me to blame it on any character. And good lord is that fricken source scary lookin' scarier than he looked the episode they killed the source and released his essence into Cole . Please Login or Register. i hate how they killed prue, they didn't end it well. Her Wiccan powers were focused on mind and movement: the ability to move objects with her mind, and the ability to project herself in an astral form. For years, her sisters thought that she was living happily in the afterlife with their mother and grandmother, though they were eventually told that Prue had been reincarnated. clearly because they have some issue. Besides this, Prue possessed the basic powers of a witch: the ability to cast spells, brew potions and scry for lost objects or people. However I'm not sure it's cause to be all Phoebe is a bitch and so selfish that she caused Prue's death.. Seriously.. What's going on with icons? Piper Halliwell (younger sister)Phoebe Halliwell (younger sister)Paige Matthews (younger maternal half-sister)Patty Halliwell (mother)Victor Bennett (father)Penny Halliwell (maternal grandmother)Allen Halliwell (maternal grandfather)Coop Halliwell (brother-in-law)P.J., Parker, and Peyton Halliwell (nieces through Phoebe and Coop)Leo Wyatt (brother-in-law via Piper)Wyatt and Chris Halliwell (nephews via Piper and Leo)Melinda Halliwell (niece via Piper and Leo)Henry Mitchell (brother-in-law)Tamora and Kat Mitchell (nieces)Henry Mitchell Jr. (adoptive nephew)Prudence Halliwell (great-niece). I loved your blog, it gave me something else to consider, since i really didnt blame anyone else other than Shax and The Source for her death. killing prue ruined the show. Episode 17 44 mins. She is the firstborn child of Patty Halliwell, a witch, and Victor Bennett, a human. Love that you actually bother with bits of script and examples. Seriously. Can not say any more than that at this time. Phoebe was not to blame at all. Why is it that practically every time a full scene plays out in my head that I am never near a computer...and then when I finally get to one I then can't recall half of it... *bangs head on desk*. The reason why Prue doesn't appear again is because Shannen has shares in Charmed and forbidded the image of her, or even a likeness ever to be used in Charmed it she would sue.